When Your slave or submissive Has Borderline Personality Disorder

Unless you’re a psychiatrist by profession, the only way you’ll probably ever discover if your sub has Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) is if he tells you. It’s difficult to diagnose, even for professionals, and it’s often mixed with other mental health issues. If you’d like to read more about the diagnostic criteria, have a look at our introductory article here.

As a Dom, a BPD sub comes with additional considerations, but not only does it not have to be a game-changer, we think it comes with some fairly attractive side benefits. Be aware of, and learn to deal with, some specific BPD behaviours, and enjoy everything that your sub brings into your life.

KNOWLEDGE IS STRENGTH

• The DSM IV lists nine diagnostic criteria. Your sub may not (and probably won’t) exhibit all of them. boydenon, for example, rarely has problems with anger impulse within the relationship. You need to understand everything you can about your sub. Quiz them if you have to. Try this free downloadable Owner’s Manual if you need help structuring questions, or set up a fun interrogation scene if that’s the way you play. You need to break down any barriers that hide information that’s important to you. his trust in confiding everything about his history and feelings to you is an important step towards a successful and healthy relationship.

• Find out about other’s experiences. Your sub may not experience BPD in the same way as anyone else, but there are many experiences that tend to be common. FetLife has a Partners of BPD group, but even better if you can find local discussion and support groups.

• You need to be a strong, calm presence. There will be storms, and to weather them you’ll need a deep sense of yourself, what you believe in and your place in the world (and their world). Like a tree, you need to have strong roots. BPD often manifests in extremes. One day you are a God, then something happens and you’re the Devil himself. History gets rewritten. All the good moments seem never to have existed and he remembers the time you did this terrible thing or said that hurtful thing. Things that you’d forgotten or thought were irrelevant get dredged up and your whole relationship is painted with new dark colours. It’s at these times that you need to:

– understand that he is not being manipulative, it feels very real to him and this is how his brain is firing at that moment
– reach deep down inside yourself and find that strong core and belief
– listen to what they’re saying and try to keep it directed and on-path
– deal with the trigger

UNDERSTANDING AND CARING FOR YOUR BPD SUBMISSIVE

• There’s no doubt that your Dominant/submissive or Master/slave relationship will be an extremely important, possibly central, part of your sub’s life. They tend to be 100%-all-in passionate people. They will over-prioritise it sometimes and you will need to gently dial it back, making sure they understand that it’s not because you think the relationship is unimportant, but because it works best for you when there is balance.

• BPD often stems from early childhood issues, such as parental or peer abuse. Like its close cousin PTSD, these issues often seem to go away until they are triggered. They can be hard to talk about, but it’s important that they are out in the open so that you are aware of them and can provide the support.

• There is a very real danger of the BPD submissive losing themselves within the relationship. They will go to great lengths to keep you happy, including letting themselves get totally absorbed in the power dynamic and losing their personal identity in the process. That places a great responsibility on you as a Dominant to not only be worthy of the trust and adoration you receive, but to keep the relationship on real, achievable, practical grounds. You need to consciously keep control and keep your sub from being totally consumed within the D/s relationship, by reminding them of who they are and what makes them special.

• My experience with boydenon is that BPD relationships are not only passionate, but can quickly morph and move under your feet. This could be something to do with the DSM IV recognised “markedly and persistently unstable self-image or sense of self”, but I think it is more that those with BPD are continual and enthusiastic explorers of identity. Roles, sense of self, and even physical desires (kinks and fetishes), can evolve quickly, so the structure of your relationship must be flexible enough to accommodate changes easily.

• Impulsive and self damaging behaviour is another DSM IV marker, and I’ll bundle this up with one more – suicidal thoughts and self-mutilating behaviour. These happen, and they’re going to be different for every BPD sub. They might range from compulsive spending, impulsive anonymous sex and binge eating, to substance abuse, to self-injury behaviours like cutting. It’s important to understand that the behaviour is outside of the control of the sub at the time, and it’s not that they are deliberately trying to damage the relationship or themselves. It is also not uncommon for this behaviour to come to light later, and possibly by accident rather than through honesty. Impulsive, compulsive and self-damaging behaviours feel personal and embarrassing. Your sub probably feels ashamed of their behaviour and would like it to disappear. For them to talk to you openly about it is a great sign of trust and intimacy, and that should always be respected. Shaming him is not going to get you anywhere, but it may drive a wedge between you. Instead, it can be the catalyst for deepening the power dynamic. The solution may be to step in to control the situation that the problem is manifesting in, such as approving credit card transactions or requiring access to online cruising profiles. If the behaviour is self injury then it may be about setting clear rules and protocols, and if it can’t be controlled seeking professional advice.

• Be very aware and wary of the BPD fear of abandonment. It’s probably the strongest and most common symptom of BPD and it’s very real. There are many ways you may need to incorporate this in your power exchange:

– Any time you relax or loosen direct control or protocol, it can be interpreted as “withdrawing your Dominance” and trigger fear. Be clear about what you are doing and why you are doing it, and monitor afterwards.
– In many ways, the more direct control you exert the more attention the sub can perceive that he is getting, so negotiation of what level of control you are willing to give can be tricky. BPD subs can want you to be involved in their lives to a greater extent than you wish to be, and in some circumstances may manipulate events to try to make that happen.
– In most D/s relationships, some amount of behavioural modification using reward/punishment is likely to play a part. Withdrawal of affection is a powerful tool, but be vary wary with BPD subs as it can easily trigger abandonment issues.
– Aftercare is important in play in any relationship, but it’s extremely important with BPD subs. Play leaves emotions raw and open, and even going to the next room to put on the kettle can trigger strong feelings.
– The concept of aftercare can be extended even further. After any small bumps in communication in the relationship, whether it’s a miscommunication in timing for meeting at a restaurant or a full-blown argument, be empathetic and ready to communicate. Small things can easily blow out of proportion. As a responsible Dom, own your mistakes and encourage your BPD sub to view you as a real person and not an infallible God.

12 Comments Add yours

  1. Angel says:

    I can tell you from experience “when your Sub (or partner in general) has BPD” Get out of that relationship. Reality is BPD’s dont need to be in a Poly or BDSM relationship at all without having a lot of prier medication / therapy treatment’s. Otherwise its vary unhealthy for them (despite them feeling its what they need), as it reinforces and encourages their disorder.

    1. boy denon says:

      hi Angel,

      i understand that it may be coming from your personal experience, however, i don’t think relationships work in a binary world of black and white/ one or zero. There are some people trapped in relationship without BPD, and there are some thrive with mental illness. It is unfair to make a blanket statements to exclude individual’s with mental differences, truths and beliefs are fluid and subjective to the type of individuals one is having. i am glad my partner didn’t “leave me simply because i was dealing with mental illness” as much as i am glad i didn’t leave my partner for that reason.

      humbly,
      boydenon

      1. Taj says:

        Hi Boy Denon,

        Would you be comfortable writing about your experience? I foubd your Dom’s post very interesting, and it’s the forst of BPD that touched home for me. I would be very interested, and grateful, to hear what you might add.

      2. Taj says:

        Hi Boy Denon,
        Would you be comfortable writing about your experience? I foubd your Dom’s post very interesting, and it’s the forst of BPD that touched home for me. I would be very interested, and grateful, to hear what you might add.

        1. boy denon says:

          Hi Taj,

          i have written about it awhile ago.
          (See: http://www.devianceanddesire.com/2014/10/bpd-disorder-cure
          http://www.devianceanddesire.com/2014/10/love-devotion/
          http://www.devianceanddesire.com/2014/09/bdsm-aftercare-and-bpd/ )

          i think my personal experience of BPD was when i was in highschool and early college time, before it evolves into something else.
          generally BPD refers to intense/extreme mood swings that happen within a short time, for a persisting time frame. For example, i might wake up one day and feel like i am optimistic about the future, i can take down the future, and with snap fingers and split second, i felt like there isn’t any point to live and became suicidal.

          But do go through the links first and comment there if you have more questions for me.

          Cheers,
          boydenon

    2. SubWithBPD says:

      Aaand…. there’s the stigma and judgment that seems to accompany that diagnosis, Angel!!!

      As someone who was diagnosed with BPD 2 years ago, at age 45, I find your comment completely insulting and typical of people who don’t seek to understand mental health issues or what others are going through. Until the diagnosis, I had no idea I even had it and neither did anyone else. Having BPD doesn’t make me unlovable or unworthy of having a fulfilling D/s relationship with my husband of 10 years. I’m curious as to how it “reinforces and encourages their disorder” because, after 35+ years of suppressing the submissive side of me and not knowing who I was or where I belonged in this world, the diagnosis actually allowed me to fully embrace, instead of shame, that part of me and I finally found a place that I felt accepted, not judged. It’s difficult enough to deal with disorder some days without having to deal with judgment from people like you.

    3. MadHatter says:

      Wow that’s really not okay to say. For some of us BDSM is incredibly healing, yes it can be dangerous but that is not always on us. I have been shamed for being submissive and for being in BDSM relationships in general. Like many people with BPD I can be sexually impulsive and have made some mistakes, and have repeatedly blamed myself for being sexually impulsive and for being kidnapped as I want willingly at first. That is not on me. That is on the person who did that to me. Now I have a Daddy who is helping me. He provides stability and the structure that I desperately need (because I also have PTSD,ASD and ADHD) through Daddy I am learning that I can and should care about myself. I’m learning that despite what I’ve always been told I can be trusted, believed and responsible and can do the hard things. My Daddy lifts me up and reassures me when my BPD symptoms make themselves known.

  2. Jess says:

    Beautiful non-shaming advice. The only thing I would add is about anger not being displayed- often anger is hard to express so if you can find a way to help that along in a healthy way, it will benefit everyone. Cheers!

  3. Darla says:

    I d like to know
    What if your dom has bpd❓
    Is it more rare?

    1. MasterMarc says:

      Hi Darla… I don’t think there is any reason to think it would be rarer on the D-side than the s-side, and I think much of boydenon’s advice in this article works in the same way for a Dom with BPD. I think the transfer of authority could add a lot of complexity. I don’t have any experience with this situation, so I’d recommend asking in the Fetlife “Partners of BPD” linked in the article.

  4. Li says:

    Hi! I am a very self-aware sub with well controlled BPD (thank god for therapy and shadow work!) and this article expressed a lot of things I have been trying to explain but doing so poorly. Thank you for providing a valuable resource.

  5. Cics says:

    Hi everyone,

    I was just diagnosed last year with ASD and BPD. Coming through lockdown and starting a relationship which led to engagement took me through a whole range of emotions, as is typical of the emotional rollercoaster.

    Right now, I’m in therapy and my fiancé and I are having to try a trial separation to give each other space after what has been a tumultuous last couple of years. We love each other, so much – but I tried to scale back my BDSM needs – I stopped going to munches, events, I lost friends, and in the end I’ve realised, it works for me. BDSM gives me structure and freedom from the noise in my head. It allows me the space to feel safe when I am in play with someone I trust and above all, it helps to re contextualise the damage which I endured in my youth.

    Having read everyone’s comments above I would argue that my participation in BDSM has strengthened my sense of self and confidence because I can now distinguish when respect is earned and when it is not. It has helped me to escape yes, but embrace the darkness inside of me. And I’m helping to heal my inner child as a result. In a recent session with a pro domme (mutually agreed as a consequence of our separation) I travelled back to where I was – a young boy being punished for nothing basically, and my domme, who also had my fiancé’s face, confusing fantasy I know, threw him out of that person out of the room. And gently closed the door.

    In therapy I’m seeking to find solace in my understanding that this parent was abused and passed that on to me. BDSM helps me feel safe again. And without, life just doesn’t make sense.

    I hope this helps people. I have a lot of love to give. And if you’re on fetlife, get in touch – the name’s – Cics. Xx

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *